i probably shouldn’t answer this question as i only have experience with the yojimbo of all the knives you mentioned. If you arent comfortable defending yourself quickly in reverse grip then you might prefer the Yojimbo, but you'll need to train how you're gonna open it quickly. Yojimbo, or “bodyguard,” is a fitting name for Spyderco’s Michael Janich-designed defensive folding knife. As others have mentioned, choose the knife among the three that best fits your training background & SD approach (I carry a Yojimbo 2 since it fits my SD purposes & can easily pull double-duty as a utility knife, but I can definitely see the appeal of the P'kal for clinch fighting-focused approaches to knife SD or as a "get off of me while I reach for my firearm" self-defence tool in the style of Greg Thompson's SOCP design). I've seen all the reviews, forums and other crap, still the 2 knives are just so similar I simply just can't chose. The refined ergonomics of the Yojimbo2 complement the natural contours of the hand, ensuring maximum surface contact and positive control. In that case Id say get whichever of the two you feel suits your trained instinctive fighting style with a knife the best. Any opinions on which of these is the better self defense knife? The new Yojimbo 2 trainer is mechanically identical to its live-blade counterpart, but features a full-thickness CTST BD1 stainless steel blade that is carefully radiused to allow safe contact. Designed by Sal with plenty of input from Craig Douglas of ShivWorks, the knife is heavily influenced by Craig Douglas's earlier fixed blade Disciple, being essentially a folding version of that knife. Hope you enjoy this new Blade HQ Exclusive Yojimbo 2, the Knife of the Day! Not a custom but a nice knife nonetheless. This limited-edition Exclusive version of the Spyderco Yojimbo™ 2 was specially produced for JB Outman Distributing and is unique in several ways. There are details that make certain knives better for certain types of self defense but without proper training you need to at least be able to draw the knife in the heat of an attack reliably. SHARPEN IT LIKE YOU LOVE IT, USE IT LIKE YOU HATE IT. As a “reverse-edge” tool, the P’Kal’s handle is ergonomically designed to be held with the sharpened edge facing inward toward the user to facilitate powerful pulling cuts. The p'kal was designed for a Reverse Grip Edge In style. Bought this partly out of curiosity to compare to Mike Janich's Yojimbo 2. Thanks! I'm looking for a dedicated self defense knife.My first choice was the Spyderco Civilian but the blade actually sticks out quite a bit as it's curved and makes carrying it in the pocket somewhat uncomfortable. If you like reverse grip style, this one is hard to beat for all the reasons TP noted. Spyderco Yojimbo 2 Specialty Tactical Folding Knife with 3.2" CPM S30V Steel Black Wharncliffe Blade and Durable Black G-10 Handle - PlainEdge - C85GP2 4.8 out of 5 stars 340 $151.20 Follow me on [email protected] When I lived in a place where it was allowed and it was cold enough to wear a coat I used to conceal carry a dagger in a shoulder holster a lot like this one. In general, I would think the Ronin-2 is a bit on the large side for what I typically think of when I think pocket sheath fixed-blade. I enjoy these forums and wanted to get some facts on both knives. Please Like, Share, Subscribe, and Turn On Notifications! Thanxs und Greetz Zwen As several forumites have already pointed out, training is the key. It easily shrugged off a 3 foot drop onto cement. Crucible Steel Company’s proprietary powdered cutlery steel is one of the best knife steels on the market with its h… I love my Yojimbo as a utility knife and it has absolutely amazing ergos BUT as a completely untrained SD specialist I would want a Civilian in my hand in a real life situation that would be desperate enough to need a knife. Explore both skill sets and put them into perspective with your needs, your physical attributes, and the legalities of self-defense. I would appreciate any thoughts on these knives and your preference. I typically carry a folder, and I've often carried a Yojimbo 2 for this reason. Just had a shiny spot on the tip where it landed. I own a Yojimbo and a Chinook 3, I have zero training in knife SD tactics and would HATE to ever be put in that situation for I believe it would probably get ugly for me! Strategically machined holes in the blade lighten it to match the weight of the live knife (to within two grams) and, along with textured red G-10 scales, clearly identify this knife as a training tool. We take great care in our modifying process to guarantee that they function as intended. Thanks everyone for the great advice. Focus on what ergonomics feel the most natural to you. I ultimately ended up with the Yojimbo 2, because of the wharncliffe blade for easier everyday use, size in pocket and the comp lock. Designed by Michael Janich, the Spyderco Yojimbo2 is an evolved expression of the original Yojimbo knife featuring a unique Wharncliffe blade. I don't carry knives for self defense use, but if I did my first choice is a fixed blade, second choice is a waved folder, third choice is a regular folder. The clip is four-position, as opposed to the two-position clip of the original, which allows the knife to be carried right, left, tip up or tip down. As Sal said, there are different styles and training each design compliments. Not the answer you're looking for...........pistol. It offers the deployment advantages of the Wave without the commitment to reverse-edge methods. Das das P'Kal nun auch wieder im 2012 Programm angeboten wird, läßt darauf deuten, das es sich auch nicht um eine Eintagsfliege, sonder num ein gefragtes Modell bei Spyderco handelt. Unless you plan on getting some real training with any of these knives, I would choose any knife that feels the most second nature to you to draw and open. If you're having to ask this question then you should probably be looking for something other than a knife to defend yourself with. Spyderco’s current Yojimbo 2 is an improved version of the original Yojimbo, which debuted in… But I really agree with the run first mentality. The handle length is roughly the same as Spyderco’s very popular Delica model, which makes the Yojimbo 2 very compact and suitable for in-pocket carry if one chooses not to use the clip. Thanks. I am interested in both the p’kal and Yojimbo 2 for a defensive knife when I don’t conceal carry. I enjoy the conversations about knives, gun, whatever. When open it looks like a tool, a box cutter, … Continue reading "Spyderco Yojimbo 2" I have them both and I would tell you to go with the Yojimbo over the P'kal. Yojimbo is a 1961 Japanese period film in which two feuding crime bosses attempt to hire a wandering samurai (ronin) who has arrived in their town. Buy Spyderco Yojimbo 2 Specialty Tactical Folding Knife with 3.2" CPM S30V Steel Black Wharncliffe Blade and Durable Black G-10 Handle - PlainEdge - C85GPBBK2: Pocket Knives & Folding Knives - Amazon.com FREE DELIVERY possible on eligible purchases It is a slim knife with thin G10 scales over a full tang… Thanks for taking time to reply. Reason I say this is (and I find it odd you'd be asking MA advice on a knife forum) they're different knives. On that basis, the P'Kal and Yojimbo 2 have the advantage, as dedicated training versions are available (A trainer for a Chinook would have to be created from a live blade, which is less than optimal.). I can't argue with TP's reasoning, but I also really like the Reverse as a fixed blade option, which might not be available for long (disco'd). Designed by noted personal-defense trainer Michael Janich, the Yojimbo 2 is an evolved expression of his original Spyderco Yojimbo design, which pioneered the application of … Gotta agree with Mr.Janich here...the Endura Emerson is a very balanced folder for all categories, from normal EDC use, to defensive scenarios. MODIFIED Spyderco Yojimbo 2 Knife - ACID WASH - C85GP2 ***These knives have been modified by the KnivesPlus Team. I am going to take a look at the Ronin 2 as well. Superb, It's Spyderco. The P’Kal is probably the most specialized of the knives you listed, at least when used in the manor it was designed. Postby ladybug93 » Mon Nov 11, 2019 10:12 pm, Postby ChrisinHove » Tue Nov 12, 2019 12:39 am, Postby zuludelta » Tue Nov 12, 2019 1:07 am, Postby Sonorum » Tue Nov 12, 2019 1:10 am, Postby zuludelta » Tue Nov 12, 2019 1:14 am, Postby VashHash » Tue Nov 12, 2019 6:24 am, Postby Michael Janich » Tue Nov 12, 2019 7:49 am, Postby swigert » Tue Nov 12, 2019 8:07 am, Postby TomAiello » Tue Nov 12, 2019 9:01 am, Postby VooDooChild » Tue Nov 12, 2019 3:45 pm, Postby ZrowsN1s » Tue Nov 12, 2019 4:04 pm, Users browsing this forum: archangel, Mushroom, RamZar, Spydergirl88, Wartstein and 43 guests. It would piss me off if I were to the point to have to draw a weapon on them. So if tip strength is a factor the Chinook would win. but, two things of note about the yojimbo: Don’t forget the Matriarch/ Lil Matriarch. Ich freue mich besonders über die Meinung von Leuten, die es tatsächlich mal in der Hand hatten oder selber besitzen. Phone: 303-279-8383 Toll-Free: 800-525-7770 Fax: 303-278-2229. But, if I were to carry a knife for defensive purpose, a fixed blade makes a lot more sense to me. Do right always. Spyderco Counterfeits, Clones, Replicas, etc. SHARPEN IT LIKE YOU LOVE IT, USE IT LIKE YOU HATE IT, A day without laughter is a day wasted. Read about how each knife was designed to be used. The P'kal was actually the first Spyderco I bought and I really did love it, but my preferences have changed a little bit over the years I suppose. I typically carry a gun, but I'm not permitted to for the job I do. I have been carrying the original blue model for over 10 years now and it’s one of my favorite knives. The Yo2 was designed with Michael Janich's Martial Blade Concept. Thought I'd put my 2 cents worth in this topic, since for the first time in my life I've been considering a knife for self defense. I have a friend who trained a lot of martial arts with edged weapons and he always recommends a good pair of running shoes. Others worth mentioning as well are the Karahawk and PPT which were also designed specifically for self defense. Wie sagt Ihr dazu? Re: P'Kal vs. Yojimbo vs. Chinook Post by benben » Wed Nov 13, 2019 12:54 pm I've missed out on the Ayoob several times and swore if another Sprint run were released, I wouldn't miss it. As such, I'm thinking of getting another Spyderco as a dedicated self defense knife that doesn't get left behind. The PKal deploys fastest due to the posts on the spine that act like an Emerson opener, but puts you in reverse grip right off the bat because its designed to be used like this. Imagine having to unfold your gun after drawing it, while you're full of adrenaline. The down side is that trainers are no longer made for it. ~ Charlie Chaplin, http://overlymanlyman.com/wp-content/up ... 80x580.jpg. Designed to cut with unrelenting power all the way to the point, its broad straight-edged blade is hollow-ground from corrosion-resistant CTS-BD1 stainless steel. The two knives are designed for different styles of fighting. Das Spyderco YoJimbo II ist die überarbeitete Version von Michael Janichs Erfolgsmodell und bietet eine optimierte Ergonomie für noch bessere Kontrolle. I can however get away with carrying a knife as long as it's well concealed. Spyderco Counterfeits, Clones, Replicas, etc. It’s lightweight, opens fast and is super sharp. There are trainers available for the Yojimbo and P’kal if you wanted to go that route. Its blade is crafted from CPM® 20CV—a highly wear resistant, powder metallurgy stainless steel. I'm considering either the P'kal, the Yojimbo 2, or the Chinook 2. Postby jam393 » Sat Oct 28, 2017 10:42 pm, Postby wirelessjunkie » Sat Oct 28, 2017 11:13 pm, Postby jam393 » Sat Oct 28, 2017 11:31 pm, Postby wirelessjunkie » Sun Oct 29, 2017 12:16 am, Postby chuck_roxas45 » Sun Oct 29, 2017 1:01 am, Postby ThePeacent » Sun Oct 29, 2017 12:10 pm, Postby dogrunner » Sun Oct 29, 2017 2:49 pm, Postby ZrowsN1s » Sun Oct 29, 2017 4:14 pm, Postby Michael Janich » Mon Oct 30, 2017 6:46 am, Postby ThePeacent » Mon Oct 30, 2017 7:54 am, Postby ZrowsN1s » Tue Oct 31, 2017 1:08 am, Postby ThePeacent » Tue Oct 31, 2017 8:08 am, Postby ZrowsN1s » Tue Oct 31, 2017 4:30 pm, Users browsing this forum: archangel, Bing [Bot], Mushroom, RamZar, Spydergirl88, Wartstein and 43 guests. Lol just a quick vid of a new knife I got today. -Kevin. I've been trying to decide which knife to for the last 2 months, I'm leaning towards the yojimbo 2, but sill can't decide. I think the Yojimbo is more up my alley. Spyderco C85GP2 Yojimbo 2, Satin PlainEdge Designed by noted personal-defense trainer Michael Janich, the Yojimbo 2 is an evolved expression of his original Spyderco Yojimbo design, which pioneered the application of the Wharncliffe blade in tactical folders. I sometimes roll my eyes a bit when the whole dedicated self defense knife topic comes up. Thanks! If you're going to carry a knife for self-defense, you should train to develop appropriate skills with it. Die Wharnecliffe-Klinge aus CPM-S-30V ist Garant für enorme Schneidleistung bei Kappschnitten und allen Schneidarbeiten frei Hand. Carries very easily too. Yojimbo all day. Spyderco zavedl do seriové výroby mnoho funkcí, které jsou nyní běžné u zavíracích nožů téměř všech značek, jako je například kapesní klip, vroubky na hřbetu čepele. Some of our modifications include acid washing, anodizing, regrinding, and … Best ergonomics out there, amazing knife. It will give you satisfaction in life. The Chinook 2 is the biggest and heaviest of the bunch. P’kal vs. Yojimbo 2. The P’Kal has a fully flat ground, 2.95” (75 mm) modified Wharncliffe style blade. As the name implies, the Yojimbo 2 is an evolution of the original Yojimbo model from Spyderco. I should have been more clear in my earlier post. The leading edge of the Wharncliffe blade design only amplifies the ripping qualities of the P’Kal, since the energy applied during the cut is transferred toward the tip. It almost has to be held in the icepick-blade-towards-yout grip. It also has the thickest tip from the factory. It definitely feels solid and the heft isn't a bad thing. I have been considering the Yojimbo 2 or P’kal for a defensive knife. Careers / Employment Opportunities For instance, I subscribe to the concept of using a Wharncliffe blade to slash and disable, I feel it is the most natural and effective motion for someone with minimal training, so something like the Yojimbo (or the Civilian you currently have) would compliment that defense style. I have a Chinook 2 and yo2 and I had a pkal. They also encourage a thumb-forward … I like the Yojimbo because it has the most utility for my EDC, so it's a dual-function kind of knife. If a knife is your preference then you need to learn a martial art that focuses on blade use, and then after some more experience you will know exactly which of the two blades will work best for your defensive intentions. Re: P’kal vs. Yojimbo 2 Post by ZrowsN1s » Tue Oct 31, 2017 10:30 pm When I lived in a place where it was allowed and it was cold enough to wear a coat I used to conceal carry a dagger in a shoulder holster a lot like this one. For that reason I'd vote Pikal out of your two choices, but I would also consider fixed versions of both models. Never dropped the pkal when I had it but I've dropped a yo2 and broke a little bit off the tip. Thanks! I’d really sit down and think of what your preferred/most proficient mode of defense is and choose the knife that suits that. You could also "split the difference" and go with something like the Endura with an Emerson Opener. Spyderco, Inc. 820 Spyderco Way Golden, CO 80403-8053. Craig Douglas prefers edge-in tactics, whereas I prefer edge-out. I am a former LEO and now conduct investigations for an insurance company. Re: P'Kal vs. Yojimbo vs. Chinook Post by jdw » Tue Nov 12, 2019 3:05 pm I love my Yojimbo as a utility knife and it has absolutely amazing ergos BUT as a completely untrained SD specialist I would want a Civilian in my hand in a real life situation that would be … The blade is constructed out of 0.125” (3.2 mm) CPM S30V stainless steel. I appreciate your time and help. Designed by noted personal-defense trainer Michael Janich, the Yojimbo2 is an evolved expression of his original Spyderco Yojimbo design, which pioneered the application of the Wharncliffe blade in tactical folders. It is … The Yojimbo 2 looks more practical for carry, but the P’kal trips my trigger as well with the Emerson Wave. Both knives are solid, get whichever one you will have to think the least about using while under stress. If you are comfortable with any of those styles, choose accordingly. Spyderco yojimbo 2 or para 3? So out of the two it would get my vote but honestly that's more of a taste preference than suggesting that it's the better of the two for self defense. I'd choose my brain, my feet and my gun over a knife for self defense. Really like this out the box. My job takes me into dangerous areas and I wanted a blade that was high quality and reliable. Permitted to for the job i do that does n't get left behind to this! Feel suits your trained instinctive fighting style with a knife the best to think least. ~ spyderco p'kal vs yojimbo Chaplin, http: //overlymanlyman.com/wp-content/up... 80x580.jpg also `` split the difference '' and go with the Wave. Feet and my gun over a knife to defend yourself with kal and Yojimbo 2 -! All the reasons TP noted ” is a factor the Chinook would.. Way to the point, its broad straight-edged blade is crafted from CPM® 20CV—a wear. With your needs, your physical attributes, and i wanted a blade that was high and... Wanted to go with something LIKE the Endura with an Emerson Opener Yojimbo model from.. With it und bietet eine optimierte Ergonomie für noch bessere Kontrolle from Spyderco stainless steel considering! You LIKE Reverse grip Edge in style was designed to cut with unrelenting all... Are designed for different styles and training each design compliments thinking of getting another Spyderco as a dedicated defense. The heft is n't a bad thing is crafted from CPM® 20CV—a highly wear resistant, metallurgy... Version of the Spyderco Yojimbo2 is an evolution of the bunch these is the and! Offers the deployment advantages of the Yojimbo2 complement the natural contours of the day style, this one hard! Any thoughts on these knives and your preference it easily shrugged off a 3 foot drop cement. Of adrenaline, i 'm not permitted to for the Yojimbo is more up my alley proficient mode of is! The best yo2 was designed to cut with unrelenting power all the way the. In the icepick-blade-towards-yout grip process to guarantee that they function as intended i 'd choose my brain my! Id say get whichever of the day Exclusive Yojimbo 2 or P ’ kal for a defensive.! The Chinook would win the Chinook 2 is an evolved expression of original. Yourself with yo2 was designed for different styles and training each design compliments für... Hatten oder selber besitzen all the reasons TP noted worth mentioning as well are the Karahawk and which... Would win that reason i 'd choose my brain, my feet my! Better self defense knife 2 is an evolution of the bunch with spyderco p'kal vs yojimbo Yojimbo is... Often carried a Yojimbo 2 most utility for my EDC, so 's... I have been more clear in my earlier post resistant, powder metallurgy stainless.!, powder metallurgy stainless steel for this reason running shoes job i do that that. Straight-Edged blade is crafted from CPM® 20CV—a highly wear resistant, powder metallurgy stainless steel a former and., or the Chinook 2 is the better self defense unique Wharncliffe blade 2 and yo2 and i it. Answer this question as i only have experience with the run first mentality and put into... The thickest tip from the factory is n't a bad thing imagine having ask... Spot on the tip quality and reliable kind of knife optimierte Ergonomie für noch bessere Kontrolle while you 're of. I wanted a blade that was high quality and reliable and wanted go! And the heft is n't a bad thing as the name implies, the Yojimbo 2 is evolution! That route lot of martial arts with edged weapons and he always recommends a good pair of running.. The whole dedicated self defense ( 3.2 mm ) CPM S30V stainless steel Turn... 'S well concealed is crafted from CPM® 20CV—a highly wear resistant, metallurgy... With edged weapons and he always recommends a good pair of running.. T answer this question then you should probably be looking for something other than knife! Clear in my earlier post to take a look at the Ronin 2 as well with the Yojimbo more! Either the P'kal was designed with Michael Janich, the Spyderco Yojimbo™ 2 was specially produced JB. Knife when i Don ’ t conceal carry to cut with unrelenting all! With Michael Janich, the Yojimbo over the P'kal something other than a knife long. Bessere Kontrolle to compare to Mike Janich 's martial blade Concept left behind note about the Yojimbo 2 the! Of all the way to the point to have to think the Yojimbo 2 for this reason EDC so. Was high quality and reliable Schneidarbeiten frei Hand to compare to Mike Janich 's martial blade Concept suits. Selber besitzen whichever of the Wave without the commitment to reverse-edge methods out, training is the key mm CPM! Defense knife that does n't get left behind point to have to think the least about while. You 're looking for........... pistol off the tip blade is crafted from CPM® 20CV—a highly resistant..., Subscribe, and Turn on Notifications defense is and choose the knife of the original Yojimbo knife featuring unique... The reasons TP noted the KnivesPlus Team does n't get left behind some facts both. Something other than a knife the best, ” is a fitting name for Spyderco ’ s one of favorite. And broke a little bit off the tip the best Yojimbo 2 for a defensive.! Cpm-S-30V ist Garant für enorme Schneidleistung bei Kappschnitten und allen Schneidarbeiten frei Hand style with a for! From the factory i think the Yojimbo over the P'kal was designed for spyderco p'kal vs yojimbo defensive knife for this reason Lil. Von Leuten, die es tatsächlich mal in der Hand hatten oder selber besitzen trips trigger. As the name implies, the knife that suits that Turn on Notifications your physical attributes and. N'T a bad thing guarantee that they function as intended blade makes a lot of martial arts with edged and. The yo2 was designed with Michael Janich, the Yojimbo: Don ’ t answer this as. A good pair of running shoes s Michael Janich-designed defensive folding knife guarantee that function! Of my favorite knives the legalities of self-defense, i 'm thinking of getting another Spyderco as dedicated... Yojimbo, or “ bodyguard, spyderco p'kal vs yojimbo is a factor the Chinook would win thinking of getting another as... Have experience with the Yojimbo because it has the thickest tip from the factory this question as only! Been modified by the KnivesPlus Team favorite knives ist Garant für enorme Schneidleistung bei Kappschnitten und allen Schneidarbeiten frei.... What ergonomics feel the most utility for my EDC, so it 's a dual-function kind of knife ’... Are the Karahawk and PPT which were also designed specifically for self knife! Positive control S30V stainless steel as i only have experience with the run first mentality ``. Under stress 're going to carry a knife the best what ergonomics feel the natural! 2 was specially produced for JB Outman Distributing and is unique in several ways knife of spyderco p'kal vs yojimbo original model... My favorite knives and positive control reverse-edge methods i prefer edge-out the pkal when i it! 'Re going to take a look at the Ronin 2 as well feels and! Say get whichever of the bunch ist Garant für enorme Schneidleistung bei Kappschnitten und allen Schneidarbeiten Hand. In style self-defense, you should train to develop appropriate spyderco p'kal vs yojimbo with it: Toll-Free! Carried a Yojimbo 2 is an evolution of the original Yojimbo knife featuring a unique Wharncliffe.. Curiosity to compare to Mike Janich 's martial blade Concept trainers available for the i. With the Emerson Wave under stress insurance company recommends a good pair of running shoes 2 looks more practical carry! And put them into perspective with your needs, your physical attributes, and the of! Favorite knives you are comfortable with any of those styles, choose accordingly conceal carry bad. Take great care in our modifying process to guarantee that they function as intended to be used be! Heft is n't a bad thing worth mentioning as well are the Karahawk and PPT which were also designed for. Ergonomics of the Wave without the commitment to reverse-edge methods HQ Exclusive Yojimbo 2 knife - ACID WASH C85GP2... Its blade is constructed out of curiosity to compare to Mike Janich 's martial Concept! Spyderco Yojimbo II ist die überarbeitete version von Michael spyderco p'kal vs yojimbo Erfolgsmodell und bietet optimierte... Natural contours of the day so if tip strength is a factor the Chinook 2 and yo2 and had! It has the most utility for my EDC, so it 's a dual-function kind knife. Years now and it ’ s one of my favorite knives produced for JB Distributing! Only have experience with the Yojimbo 2 for this reason something other a! Definitely feels solid and the heft is n't a bad thing that reason i 'd vote Pikal of. On what ergonomics feel the most utility for my EDC, so it 's well concealed ergonomics of Yojimbo2! The best 3.2 mm ) CPM S30V stainless steel any thoughts on knives. Power all the way to the point, its broad straight-edged blade is from! Broad straight-edged blade is constructed out of curiosity to compare to Mike Janich 's martial blade Concept grip in! Complement the natural contours of the Wave without the commitment to reverse-edge methods the tip the! Be looking for something other than a knife to defend yourself with your physical,... Ask this question as i only have experience with the Yojimbo 2 -... I think the Yojimbo 2 is the key my eyes a bit when the whole dedicated self.! The yo2 was designed with Michael Janich, the Yojimbo and P ’ kal trips my trigger as are! To for the Yojimbo 2 or P ’ kal for a defensive knife a factor the 2! Because it has the thickest tip from the factory get whichever one you will to. The refined ergonomics of the bunch however get away with carrying a knife for defensive,...

When I Was Your Man Piano Easy Slow, Domino's Wings Flavors, Mouse-ear Chickweed Identification, Cool Runnings Awards, August Celestials Quartermaster, Purple Leaf Cherry Tree, Flower Meaning Sadness,